NiTRO Creative Matters

Perspectives on creative arts in higher education

More than Money – Expanding Definitions of Success for Arts Alumni

In higher education, we like to throw around the term “successful” when referring to our alumni, but what do we really mean by that?  Employed, certainly (if that is their goal).  Financially stable, making enough money to have a decent quality of life.  But beyond that, is more money really the best way to measure more success?  What else should we consider in this assessment?

 

By Dr Angie Miller

In higher education, we like to throw around the term “successful” when referring to our alumni, but what do we really mean by that?  Employed, certainly (if that is their goal).  Financially stable, making enough money to have a decent quality of life.  But beyond that, is more money really the best way to measure more success?  What else should we consider in this assessment?

. . .we found that selected SNAAP items are able to measure two distinct types of job satisfaction: Intrinsic Satisfaction Aspects and Extrinsic Satisfaction Aspects. ., the magnitude of the relationship for overall job satisfaction was higher for intrinsic . . . suggesting that intrinsic satisfaction may play a larger role in how arts alumni think about their occupational success

It is not surprising, given the rising costs of college and burgeoning student debt, that there is an increased emphasis on the money that students earn post-graduation. Arts majors in particular have been under fire for low income levels, especially among recent college graduates. But this focus on income might not really capture the whole picture when it comes to “success” among arts graduates. Do we not want graduates to find meaning and fulfillment in their work as well?

The findings from my recent study, co-authored with Amber D. Dumford, “Assessing Alumni Success: Income is NOT the Only Outcome,” indicate that institutions need to assess other aspects of occupational experiences, reimagining our understanding of student preparedness and alumni success.  This was a quantitative study that utilized data from the Strategic National Arts Alumni Project (SNAAP), a multi-institution online alumni survey designed to obtain knowledge of arts education in the United States.  Combining data from the 2011, 2012, and 2013 administrations, which includes 92,113 alumni from 155 institutions, we found several points of interest concerning alumni perspectives on career paths and success.

Using exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis, we found that selected SNAAP items are able to measure two distinct types of job satisfaction:  Intrinsic Satisfaction Aspects and Extrinsic Satisfaction Aspects

Intrinsic Satisfaction Aspects

Extrinsic Satisfaction Aspects

Work that reflects my personality, interests, and values

Income

Opportunity to be creative

Job security

Opportunity to contribute to the greater good

Opportunity for career advancement

While both of these types of satisfaction were significantly related to OVERALL job satisfaction, the magnitude of the relationship for overall job satisfaction was higher for intrinsic than for extrinsic, suggesting that intrinsic satisfaction may play a larger role in how arts alumni think about their occupational success. 

Regression analyses revealed many strong relationships between alumni characteristics and alumni job satisfaction, both intrinsic and extrinsic. Not surprisingly, the strongest predictor of extrinsic job satisfaction was income. In contrast, the strongest predictor of intrinsic job satisfaction was how related their arts training was to the occupation in which they spend the majority of their time. Furthermore, those spending the majority of their work time in arts-related professions reported slightly more intrinsic and somewhat less extrinsic job satisfaction, suggesting that having a job in one’s desired field is an important component of satisfaction. While to a small degree, those outside the arts are more extrinsically satisfied, to a much larger degree those in arts-related occupations are more intrinsically satisfied. 

If we consider “success” to encompass support and involvement in community organizations, and engaging in meaningful individual interests and activities as a well-rounded human being, then we have plenty of evidence that arts alumni enjoy success in these areas.

Beyond this study, there are also other items on SNAAP that can provide alternate measures of success outside of income.  Looking at whether or not alumni went on to further education, whether or not they completed the additional degree(s), at which institutions, and how well prepared they were, can offer evidence for success in guiding alumni for their future educational pursuits.  SNAAP also asks respondents to report on the relevance of their educational training to their first job after graduation, as well as their current job where they spend a majority of their work time.  Furthermore, open-ended questions can provide valuable information, and SNAAP incorporates several throughout the questionnaire, including one prompting alumni to “describe how your arts training is or is not relevant to your current work.”

We might even want to consider components of success outside of one’s career.  SNAAP asks about different types of involvement in the arts community, such as volunteering at or serving on the board of arts organizations, volunteering to teach the arts, donating money to organizations or artists, and attending arts events.  Do alumni continue their arts practice in their own personal time?  (Spoiler alert: the vast majority – 77% – do so.)  If we consider “success” to encompass support and involvement in community organizations, and engaging in meaningful individual interests and activities as a well-rounded human being, then we have plenty of evidence that arts alumni enjoy success in these areas.

Although SNAAP focuses on graduates of arts programs, this could extend to other fields such as social services, education, and humanities.  Students do not expect to make as much money upon graduation, but may be pursuing a career in the field because they enjoy the work or the good that they can do with their degree. Their education may be developing skills and values that allow them to make social contributions in a variety of ways.  Attention to income as a the sole measure of educational quality could have a negative impact on disciplines that are not traditionally associated with financial rewards, despite serving great purpose to society and providing workers with a sense of personal value and fulfillment. Therefore, institutions should consider expanding their definition of “success” when attempting to demonstrate evidence of a “return on investment” for education.   


Full article citation:

Dumford, A.D., & Miller, A.L. (2017).  Assessing alumni success: Income is NOT the only outcome!  Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 42(2), 195-207. doi: 10.1080/02602938.2015.1098587. 


Angie L. Miller is an Associate Research Scientist at the Indiana University Center for Postsecondary Research. She holds a Ph.D. in Educational Psychology from Ball State University. Currently, she does research and data analytic support for the National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE) and the Strategic National Arts Alumni Project (SNAAP). Her research interests include creativity assessment, the utilization of creativity in educational settings, factors impacting gifted student engagement, arts education, and survey methodology.

More from this issue

More from this issue

Writing twenty years ago, Neumann (1996) questioned the existence of a nexus between research and teaching roles. Reviewing the literature up until the late-1980s, she asserted that few academics find a nexus because of the privileging of research over teaching. From the 1990s, however, she found the research-teaching nexus to be bi-directional and multi-level, with many students identifying the nexus as an opportunity for scholarly interactions. . . . This short discussion paper retains the focus on the artist academic and further extends the ART nexus through the addition of employability.

In the last thirty to forty years there has been a concerted drive in the Australian academy, to justify creative arts training in forms that articulate with economic worth, vocational function and government policy. . . . While there have been great gains in recognising the value of creative work within academic frameworks, their effect on the creative academics who deliver these graduate outcomes remains underexplored. . .

 

Emerging out of a multidisciplinary history, including an ongoing relationship with the West Australian Academy of Performing Arts (WAAPA), the School of Arts and Humanities at Edith Cowan University has shaped and honed a contemporary focus through actively defining the usefulness of art for today’s society whether that be through praxis or pedagogy or a hybrid of the two. The ethos of the school is to explore and experiment and to push back from pre-determined understandings – to collaborate, innovate and find solutions through a merging of making and theory often employing whatever is to hand.

I completed a double degree in Music and Law at Monash University, graduating from music in 2010 and from law in 2013 The opportunity to study under the guidance of Australia’s leading performing jazz artists and alongside talented peers was a dream come true.

 

Over the last ten years, I have engaged in a number of research projects exploring the impact of a higher education degree in the creative and performing arts for graduates seeking a career in the creative industries. In essence, I have discovered that a creative arts degree provides students with three significant career-building opportunities. . . On the other side of the coin, . . . graduates in industry often report that they are insufficiently prepared for the complex nature of the creative industries work environments

Georgie Meagher graduated with undergraduate and masters degrees in Creative Arts (Performance) from the University of Wollongong in 2008. She is now CEO of Next Wave Australia’s most comprehensive platform for emerging artists whichincludes learning programs and a biennial festival.  NiTRO editor, Jenny Wilson, spoke with her about the influence of her university years, her role as an alumni and her advice for graduating students.

After six decades of music education, Queensland Conservatorium Griffith University graduates are making their mark in the performing arts industry, both in Australia and abroad. its alumni include players in leading positions in every Australian state orchestra, and a host of Grammy and ARIA award winners and many internationally recognised musicians including Dami Im, Jayson Gillham, Katie Noonan, Piers Lane, Megan Washington, Kate Miller-Heidke, Lisa Gasteen and Brett Dean have all passed through the Queensland Conservatorium.

LinkedIn has been described as the non-sexy, sleeping dragon of social media (Buck, 2012).  It has become the premiere social media site for professionals; most employers in the UK will search for a job candidate on LinkedIn.  This makes it very useful when searching for jobs internships, exploring careers or accessing company information. Yet, while students may be active on other social media platforms they are less engaged with LinkedIn. Certainly our creative students report that LinkedIn has little appeal

What do students of art need to know and be able to do today in order to flourish tomorrow? For the past ten years I have been exploring this question within the context of US art schools (Salazar, 2013a, 2013b, 2014, 2016). Reflecting on this body of research, three strategies stand out by which we, as educators, can better prepare art students to meet future challenges. We need to prompt inquiry, nurture entrepreneurial dispositions, and facilitate creative communities of practice.

Independent artists are faced with a challenging and transforming landscape that requires adaptive resilience in order to thrive creatively, today and in the future. How do we, as tertiary educators, empower and enable artists to build strong and flexible, professional contemporary art practices? To address this issue, my current research draws models of praxis from artist-run initiatives (ARI) in the Visual Arts industry, specifically from my experience as director of Boxcopy Contemporary Art Space.

If one was to believe the various reports emanating from the popular media, creative arts schools provide a waiting room for global graduate unemployment.  As we all know, nothing could be further from the truth or, as the US Herberger Institute for Design and the Arts puts it ‘Uncle Henry is Wrong’.